LSAT Strengthen and Weaken Questions: A Simple Method
Strengthen and weaken questions ask which answer makes an argument more or less convincing. They don't need to prove or disprove the conclusion, just move it.
Step 1: Break down the argument
- What's the conclusion?
- What's the evidence?
- What assumption connects them?
Step 2: Target the assumption
- To strengthen: support the assumption or rule out an alternative explanation.
- To weaken: attack the assumption or introduce an alternative explanation.
Practice LSAT questions the way you already scroll
Tendle is a free study feed with original LSAT-style questions and explanations. Swipe a few cards a day, review what you missed, and grow your Tendle from a tiny Seed to Radiant Tendle.
Try Tendle freeCausal arguments
Many LSAT arguments claim that A causes B. Common weakeners:
- Something else causes B
- B actually causes A
- The correlation is coincidence
- B happened without A
Strengtheners do the opposite, like ruling out alternative causes.
Watch for scope
The right answer must relate to the argument's specific conclusion. Answers that are about a related but different topic are traps.
Accept new information
On strengthen and weaken questions, assume each answer choice is true. Your job is to judge its effect, not whether it's realistic.
Practice
Strengthen and weaken are common question types. Daily practice with careful review builds the instinct for spotting gaps quickly.
Try it: 3 practice questions from Tendle
Answer each one before you open the explanation. That retrieval attempt is where the learning happens.
1. Archaeologist: "The pottery shards at the river site were made by the Hollow Creek people. Hollow Creek pottery is the only regional style that mixes crushed shell into the clay, and these shards contain crushed shell." Which most strengthens the argument?
- Crushed shell could not have entered the clay at the river site through natural processes after the pots were made.
- The Hollow Creek people lived closer to the river site than their neighbors did.
- Hollow Creek pottery is often decorated with spiral patterns.
- Several of the shards have spiral patterns.
- The neighbors traded frequently with the Hollow Creek people.
Show answer
Answer: A. The argument depends on the shell being a deliberate ingredient. A rules out the main alternative, later contamination. B and D add some support, but A protects the key evidence itself. E weakens the argument, since traded pots could end up anywhere.
Source: Logical Reasoning question types, LSAC (question type description)
2. After the city added protected bike lanes on Harlan Avenue, reported cycling injuries on that avenue fell by 30 percent over the following year. Therefore, adding protected bike lanes to other major avenues would reduce cycling injuries citywide.
Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?
- Many cyclists said the new lanes made them feel safer.
- Injuries rose on avenues that did not get protected lanes.
- The lanes cost more to build than the city had projected.
- In the year after the lanes were installed, a nearby subway extension opened, and many cyclists who had used Harlan Avenue switched to the subway.
- Several other cities saw similar declines after adding protected lanes.
Show answer
Answer: D. An alternative explanation, fewer cyclists, accounts for the drop without the lanes improving safety. Several choices strengthen the argument instead.
Source: The LSAT: Logical Reasoning, LSAC
3. Archaeologist: Pottery shards found at the Kell site bear a glaze otherwise known only from the Varro region, 300 kilometers away. So the people of the Kell settlement must have traded with the Varro region.
Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the archaeologist's argument?
- The minerals that produce this glaze also occur in deposits a few kilometers from the Kell site.
- Other goods from the Varro region have never been found at the Kell site.
- The Varro region produced large amounts of pottery.
- Trade routes in the period often covered more than 300 kilometers.
- The shards at the Kell site are slightly older than most Varro pottery.
Show answer
Answer: A. If the glaze could be made from local materials, the shards need not have come through trade. The first choice weakens only a little, since absence of other goods is weaker evidence.
Source: The LSAT: Logical Reasoning, LSAC
These are real cards from Tendle's LSAT feed. The app has 1,000+ more, with spaced review of the ones you miss. Get Tendle free on the App Store.
Practice LSAT questions the way you already scroll
Tendle is a free study feed with original LSAT-style questions and explanations. Swipe a few cards a day, review what you missed, and grow your Tendle from a tiny Seed to Radiant Tendle.
Download on theApp StoreTendle is an independent study app and is not affiliated with or endorsed by any exam owner. Exam formats and policies change, so always confirm details with the official testing organization. Practice results don't predict exam scores.