LSAT Flaw Questions: Common Reasoning Errors to Know
Flaw questions ask you to describe what's wrong with an argument. The LSAT reuses a set of classic flaws. Learn to recognize them and these questions get much faster.
Common flaws
- Correlation vs. causation: assuming that because two things occur together, one causes the other
- Sufficient vs. necessary confusion: treating a requirement as a guarantee, or the reverse
- Unrepresentative sample: drawing a broad conclusion from a biased or small sample
- Ad hominem: attacking the person instead of the argument
- Circular reasoning: assuming the conclusion in the evidence
- Equivocation: using a word in two different senses
- False choice: assuming only two options exist
- Part-to-whole: assuming what's true of parts is true of the whole, or vice versa
- Absence of evidence: concluding something is false because it hasn't been proven true
Practice LSAT questions the way you already scroll
Tendle is a free study feed with original LSAT-style questions and explanations. Swipe a few cards a day, review what you missed, and grow your Tendle from a tiny Seed to Radiant Tendle.
Try Tendle freeHow to approach flaw questions
- Identify conclusion and evidence
- Find the gap
- Name the flaw in your own words
- Match it to an answer choice
Read answer choices carefully
Flaw answers are often written abstractly. Translate each one to see whether it describes what actually happened in the argument.
Practice
Learning flaws pays off across the LR section, since many question types depend on spotting weak reasoning.
Try it: 3 practice questions from Tendle
Answer each one before you open the explanation. That retrieval attempt is where the learning happens.
1. If the bridge inspection finds cracks, the county closes the bridge. And the bridge inspection found cracks. So the county closed the bridge.
Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its pattern of reasoning to the argument above?
- Some paintings in the east gallery are works insured by the museum, and some works insured by the museum are works listed in the museum's catalog. So some paintings in the east gallery are works listed in the museum's catalog.
- All pilots at the regional airline are employees certified for night flights. Captain Shaw is one of the pilots at the regional airline. So Captain Shaw is one of the employees certified for night flights.
- All products in the fall catalog are items tested by the quality team. The travel kettle is not one of the items tested by the quality team. So the travel kettle is not one of the products in the fall catalog.
- If the museum receives the grant, it will extend its weekend hours. But the museum did not receive the grant. So the museum will not extend its weekend hours.
- All farms in Clay County are farms enrolled in the water program. So all farms enrolled in the water program are farms in Clay County.
Show answer
Answer: B. The argument is valid. The correct choice has exactly the same logical structure, even though one is stated with "if…then" and the other with "all". Each other choice has a different structure, such as denying a condition or reversing the inference.
Source: The LSAT: Logical Reasoning, LSAC
2. If the novel wins the award, its publisher orders a second printing. And the novel won the award. So the publisher ordered a second printing.
Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its pattern of reasoning to the argument above?
- If the team wins its final game, it qualifies for the tournament. And the team qualified for the tournament. So the team won its final game.
- If a student misses more than five classes, she must meet with an advisor. But Priya does not have to meet with an advisor. So Priya did not miss more than five classes.
- All cars in the company fleet are vehicles serviced at the north garage. So all vehicles serviced at the north garage are cars in the company fleet.
- All members of the chess club are students who attended the strategy workshop. Marcus is one of the members of the chess club. So Marcus is one of the students who attended the strategy workshop.
- Some trees in Linden Park are trees treated for beetles this year, and some trees treated for beetles this year are trees tagged by the forestry office. So some trees in Linden Park are trees tagged by the forestry office.
Show answer
Answer: D. The argument is valid. The correct choice has exactly the same logical structure, even though one is stated with "if…then" and the other with "all". Each other choice has a different structure, such as denying a condition or reversing the inference.
Source: The LSAT: Logical Reasoning, LSAC
3. If a student misses more than five classes, she must meet with an advisor. And Priya missed more than five classes. So Priya must meet with an advisor.
Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its pattern of reasoning to the argument above?
- All nurses on the night shift are staff trained in emergency triage. So all staff trained in emergency triage are nurses on the night shift.
- If a patient's fever lasts more than three days, the clinic orders a blood test. If the clinic orders a blood test, the patient is scheduled for a follow-up visit. So if a patient's fever lasts more than three days, the patient is scheduled for a follow-up visit.
- All novels on the summer list are books ordered by the library. The Quiet Shore is one of the novels on the summer list. So The Quiet Shore is one of the books ordered by the library.
- Some farms in Clay County are farms enrolled in the water program, and some farms enrolled in the water program are farms that receive a monthly report. So some farms in Clay County are farms that receive a monthly report.
- If the reservoir drops below 40 percent of capacity, the city restricts lawn watering. And the city is restricting lawn watering. So the reservoir has dropped below 40 percent of capacity.
Show answer
Answer: C. The argument is valid. The correct choice has exactly the same logical structure, even though one is stated with "if…then" and the other with "all". Each other choice has a different structure, such as denying a condition or reversing the inference.
Source: The LSAT: Logical Reasoning, LSAC
These are real cards from Tendle's LSAT feed. The app has 1,000+ more, with spaced review of the ones you miss. Get Tendle free on the App Store.
Practice LSAT questions the way you already scroll
Tendle is a free study feed with original LSAT-style questions and explanations. Swipe a few cards a day, review what you missed, and grow your Tendle from a tiny Seed to Radiant Tendle.
Download on theApp StoreTendle is an independent study app and is not affiliated with or endorsed by any exam owner. Exam formats and policies change, so always confirm details with the official testing organization. Practice results don't predict exam scores.